Cream & SlushFind
Milkshake

Peanut Butter Banana Honey Milkshake

By Marty Cole Β· October 23, 2026

πŸ’ Be the first to rate this
πŸ₯„ 10 min prep❄️ 24 hr freeze🍦 1 pint
NuttyCreamySweet
Peanut Butter Banana Honey Milkshake

Freeze the banana slices before you blend the base, not after, and your Peanut Butter Banana Honey Milkshake will come out of the Ninja Creami smooth and scoopable instead of weirdly grainy. I learned that the hard way on batch one. Whole milk, heavy cream, ripe banana, peanut butter, a drizzle of honey, all blended and frozen for a full day. My wife took one sip and said it tastes like the peanut butter shake from the food court, which, honestly, is exactly what I was going for.

How it spins

🍦
Program
Milkshake
❄️
Freeze
24 hrs
πŸ₯„
Prep
10 min
πŸ₯‘
Makes
1 pint

Tip: freeze the pint on a level shelf for a full 24 hours. If the first spin looks crumbly, add a splash of milk and run Re-spin.

Ingredients

  • Whole Milk0.75 cup
  • Heavy Cream0.25 cup
  • Ripe Banana1 medium
  • Creamy Peanut Butter3 tbsp
  • Honey2 tbsp
  • Vanilla Extract0.5 tsp
  • Pinch of Salt1 pinch
  • Whipped Creamoptional2 tbsp
  • Honey Drizzleoptional1 tsp

Directions

  1. 1Mash the ripe banana thoroughly with a fork until completely smooth, then whisk together with the whole milk, heavy cream, peanut butter, honey, vanilla extract, and salt in a bowl until fully combined and no streaks remain.
  2. 2Pour the base into your Ninja Creami pint container, filling to the max fill line. Place the lid on the pint and set it on a flat, level surface in your freezer.
  3. 3Freeze for 24 hours until the base is completely solid throughout. Do not disturb the pint during freezing, as an even freeze helps the machine process smoothly.
  4. 4Remove the pint from the freezer and let it sit at room temperature for 5 minutes to temper slightly. Install the pint into the Ninja Creami outer bowl and lock it into the machine.
  5. 5Select the MILKSHAKE preset and allow the machine to complete its full cycle. Once finished, check the consistency.
  6. 6If the texture appears crumbly or icy, add a small splash of whole milk directly to the pint and run the Re-spin function until the milkshake is thick, creamy, and smooth.
  7. 7Scoop into a chilled glass, top with whipped cream and an optional drizzle of honey, and serve immediately.

Tips

  • Freeze your pint completely solid for the full 16-24 hours before spinning; a partially frozen pint will come out too icy or crumbly.
  • If your result looks powdery or granular after spinning, add a splash of milk or cream, pop it back in the Creami, and re-spin on the same setting for a creamier texture.
  • Let the frozen pint sit on the counter for 2-3 minutes before inserting it into the machine; this slight softening helps the Creami spin more smoothly without jamming.

Variations

  • Swap half the honey for maple syrup and add a pinch of cinnamon before freezing for a fall-inspired flavor.
  • Use natural peanut butter instead of creamy, then add an extra teaspoon of honey to balance the texture since natural PB is thinner.

FAQ

Can I use skim milk instead of whole milk?
You can, but the result will be thinner and less creamy after spinning. Stick with whole milk or add an extra tablespoon of heavy cream to keep that rich texture.
What if my pint didn't freeze solid after 24 hours?
Your freezer may run warmer than average. Give it another 6-12 hours, or check that the pint is sitting flat on a level surface with nothing blocking airflow around it.
Can I make this lighter or lower in calories?
Replace half the heavy cream with whole milk and reduce the honey by a teaspoon, then use the Lite Ice Cream setting on your Creami for a fluffier result.
How long does the frozen pint last in the freezer?
Keep it sealed and it will stay good for up to 2 weeks; after that, freezer burn can affect the texture and flavor when you spin it.

Nutrition

Per serving Β· makes about 2 servings Β· estimated

412
Calories
11g
Protein
39g
Carbs
28g
Sugar
21g
Fat

Ratings & Reviews

No ratings yet

Be the first to rate and review this recipe!

Marty Cole, recipe developer at Cream & Slush

Meet Marty Cole

I'm a home cook who got a little obsessed with the Ninja Slushi and Creami. I test every recipe in my own kitchen on a real machine, dial in the texture, and only post the ones my family actually finishes.

More about me β†’

More Milkshake recipes

Browse all β†’