Classic Cookies & Cream
By Marty Cole · June 7, 2026
🍒 Be the first to rate this
Classic Cookies & Cream was the recipe that finally got my wife to stop side-eyeing the Ninja Creami taking up counter space. The trick most people miss is the softened cream cheese in the base, which gives it that thick, almost cheesecake-y body that store cookies and cream never has. I fold the crushed cookies in at the re-spin so they stay crunchy instead of turning to mush. It scoops up creamy with real cookie chunks throughout. My kids now request it by name, which means I'm buying sandwich cookies in bulk like it's my job.
How it spins
Tip: freeze the pint on a level shelf for a full 24 hours. If the first spin looks crumbly, add a splash of milk and run Re-spin.
Ingredients
- Whole Milk1 cup
- Heavy Cream0.75 cup
- Cream Cheese, Softened2 tbsp
- Granulated Sugar0.33 cup
- Vanilla Extract1 tsp
- Chocolate Sandwich Cookies, Brokenoptional5 whole
Directions
- 1Whisk the softened cream cheese with the sugar until smooth, then blend in the milk and cream.
- 2Stir in the vanilla until the base is silky and the sugar has dissolved.
- 3Pour into a Creami pint below the max line, seal, and freeze flat for 24 hours.
- 4Spin on the ICE CREAM preset, adding milk and a Re-spin if crumbly.
- 5Press the broken cookies into a central well and run the Mix-In program to distribute them.
- 6Serve right away for the best cookie crunch.
Tips
- Freeze your pint completely flat and level in the coldest part of your freezer for a full 24 hours; this ensures the Creami can process it smoothly without crumbly texture.
- If your result comes out powdery or too icy after spinning, add just a splash of cold milk or heavy cream and re-spin it to get that creamy consistency.
- Let the frozen pint sit at room temperature for 2-3 minutes before inserting it into the Creami; this helps it spin more evenly without stalling.
Variations
- Crush 8-10 Oreos into chunks and fold them in before freezing, then spin on the Ice Cream setting for a loaded Cookies and Cream version.
- Use half and half instead of heavy cream for a lighter, less rich ice cream that still freezes solid and spins beautifully.
- Add 1 tablespoon of instant espresso powder to the base for a coffee-flavored twist that pairs great with crushed cookies.
FAQ
- Can I make this with less cream to cut the calories?
- Yes, swap the heavy cream for an equal amount of whole milk or half and half; it will still freeze solid and spin into a smooth texture, just slightly less rich.
- Why did my mixture not freeze solid after 24 hours?
- Your freezer might not be cold enough, or the pint wasn't placed flat; try setting it in the coldest spot for a full 24 hours and keep your freezer at 0 degrees Fahrenheit or below.
- What should I do if the Creami result is too crumbly?
- Stop immediately, add a small splash of cold milk or cream, and run the Ice Cream program again to re-spin and smooth out the texture.
- How long can I store the frozen pint before using it?
- You can keep it frozen for up to 2-3 weeks; just make sure your freezer stays consistently cold and the pint stays sealed or covered tightly.
Nutrition
Per serving · makes about 2 servings · estimated
Ratings & Reviews
No ratings yetBe the first to rate and review this recipe!
Meet Marty Cole
I'm a home cook who got a little obsessed with the Ninja Slushi and Creami. I test every recipe in my own kitchen on a real machine, dial in the texture, and only post the ones my family actually finishes.
More about me →
